Last updated: November 17, 2026
You’re at the feed store looking at timothy, alfalfa, bermuda, and teff, and every one is priced differently. Which one does your horse need, and is the expensive bale worth it?
Here’s where each hay fits, when paying more makes sense, and what to watch when you change loads.
Table of Contents
Timothy vs. Alfalfa vs. Bermuda vs. Teff: Quick Comparison
| Hay | Type | Crude protein examples | Best suited for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Timothy | Cool-season grass | About 8% to 11% | Most adult horses in light to moderate work | Can run higher in sugar than warm-season grasses; often pricey in the South |
| Alfalfa | Legume | About 17% to 22% | Growing horses, nursing mares, hard keepers, heavy work | Rich in calories and calcium; blister beetles in some regions |
| Bermuda | Warm-season grass | About 9% to 11%, lower when mature | Maintenance horses and easy keepers in the South | Quality varies a lot; Coastal bermuda has been linked to impaction colic |
| Teff | Warm-season annual grass | Varies; late-cut teff can run short | Easy keepers and horses that need lower-sugar hay | Don’t assume it’s low in sugar; some horses need time to accept it |
These are example values from published forage references, not guaranteed numbers for every bale. The timothy examples come from equine nutritionist Laurie Lawrence’s conference paper, hosted by UC Davis. Oklahoma State University Extension lists bermudagrass at about 9% to 11% crude protein and early-bloom alfalfa at 17% to 22%. Actual values vary with maturity and growing conditions, so test the hay you’re feeding. Alfalfa also carries more digestible energy per pound than grass hay, so it’s the richer feed even when protein isn’t the concern.

Bermuda vs. Alfalfa Hay
At my barn in Louisiana, bermuda is the everyday grass hay, and alfalfa serves a different purpose. Bermuda typically has less protein and digestible energy than alfalfa, and alfalfa carries considerably more calcium.
Calcium is worth a closer look with bermuda. The Merck Veterinary Manual warns that warm-season grasses can run low in calcium or carry oxalates that interfere with calcium uptake. That doesn’t make bermuda bad hay, but don’t assume the minerals are balanced just because a horse is eating plenty of it. A hay test and a look at the whole ration will show any gaps.
Ulcers are one place alfalfa has an edge. In a Texas A&M study, ulcer scores were significantly lower on alfalfa hay and concentrate than on bermuda hay and the same concentrate. The researchers credited alfalfa’s higher calcium and protein with buffering stomach acid. Alfalfa can help as part of how you feed, but it won’t cure an active ulcer, so a horse with symptoms still needs your vet.
In much of the South, locally grown bermuda is the more economical base hay. Compared with alfalfa, it supplies fewer calories and less protein, which makes it a better fit for horses that hold their weight easily. Alfalfa makes more sense when a horse needs more. Plenty of Southern barns feed bermuda as the base and add some alfalfa for the horses that need it.
One caution: Coastal bermuda has been associated with ileal impaction, a blockage in the last part of the small intestine. University of Georgia researchers say mixing it with another hay doesn’t appear to eliminate that risk, and they point to hay quality, water intake, and other factors too. If your horse has had an ileal impaction, ask your vet about avoiding Coastal bermuda rather than blending it with alfalfa. Varieties, colic, and buying tips are in bermuda hay for horses.

Timothy Hay vs. Alfalfa Hay
Neither is better across the board. They do different jobs. Timothy is a cool-season grass that’s usually soft, palatable, and moderate in protein and calories, which makes it a common all-around hay for adult horses in light to moderate work. Maturity matters more than the cutting number: in Lawrence’s figures, early-bloom timothy ran close to 11% protein and late-bloom hay under 8%.
Timothy has two drawbacks. Outside the regions where it grows well, it has to be shipped in, so it often costs more than local hay. And as a cool-season grass, it can carry more sugar than people expect, so it isn’t automatically right for a metabolic horse. Judge it by how leafy, clean, and fresh it is, using the checks in the guide to choosing hay for horses.

Alfalfa is a legume, higher in protein, calories, and calcium than timothy, which makes it useful for growing horses, hard keepers, and horses with high energy demands. It isn’t automatically off-limits for an easy keeper, but the amount matters. Fed freely, it can supply more calories than the horse needs, so judge it as part of the whole ration.
Kentucky Equine Research notes that alfalfa often runs over 1% calcium, with a calcium-to-phosphorus ratio of 3:1 to 6:1, much wider than grass hay. If alfalfa makes up most of your horse’s forage, have the whole ration checked to make sure calcium, phosphorus, and other nutrients are balanced.
For a lot of horses, the answer is both. Grass hay with some alfalfa adds calories and protein without leaning entirely on alfalfa, and I walk through the amounts in how much alfalfa to feed a horse. Buy alfalfa from a grower you trust, since it can carry toxic blister beetles in some regions.

Teff Hay vs. Bermuda
Teff and bermuda are both warm-season grasses, but teff is an annual that’s replanted every year, while bermuda is a perennial. Teff has caught on for easy keepers because Kentucky Equine Research calls it often low in sugar and starch. In one study it cites, teff tested 5.4% to 8.4% nonstructural carbohydrates (NSC) across cutting stages, though that’s one study, not a promise for every load. Cut at the right stage, it’s fine-stemmed and soft.
That doesn’t automatically make it better. KER also notes that late-cut teff can fall short on protein, and that horses in preference trials picked alfalfa and timothy over teff, though most eat it fine once they’re used to it. A soft, leafy bermuda bale can suit a horse better than a mature teff bale, and in much of the South, bermuda is easier to find from local growers.
Hay for Easy Keepers and Metabolic Horses
An easy keeper and a metabolic horse aren’t quite the same feeding problem. For an easy keeper, total calories are the issue. For a horse with insulin dysregulation, such as EMS, or a history of laminitis, the tested sugar and starch matter too, more than whether the bale says timothy, bermuda, or teff. Oregon State University Extension notes that cool-season grasses like timothy tend to run higher in sugar than warm-season grasses like bermuda and teff, but it also says grass species alone is a poor guide.
Even if a hay tests low in sugar, you still need to watch how much the horse eats and whether the whole ration covers its needs. Lab reports don’t all list carbohydrates the same way, so ask your vet or an equine nutritionist which numbers matter for your horse.
Soaking can lower sugar, but don’t count on it to make an unsuitable hay safe. The University of Kentucky describes orchardgrass that lost about 40% of its sugar and starch after an hour of soaking, which isn’t a guaranteed result for another load. Soaking also pulls out protein and minerals, and soaked hay should be fed right away so it doesn’t mold. For a metabolic horse, work out a testing and soaking plan with your vet or nutritionist. A slow-feed hay net also helps an easy keeper stretch a measured ration over the day.

Switching Between Hay Types
I keep a small notebook in my truck for daily horse notes. When one of my mares dropped about 75 pounds over six weeks, those notes showed the weight loss followed a change in hay supplier, and that’s what I took to the vet. It’s why I don’t treat a new load as interchangeable with the last one.
For most healthy horses, mix the new hay in with the old over 7 to 14 days, and watch manure, appetite, and body condition as you go. Go slower, and talk with your vet, for a horse with a history of colic, ulcers, or metabolic disease. Weigh the hay instead of counting flakes, since flakes from a new supplier can weigh very differently, and base the daily amount on how much hay a horse needs.
Hay Type FAQs
Is bermuda hay good for horses?
Yes. Good-quality bermuda hay works well for many adult horses, especially in the South where it’s local. Its value depends on variety, maturity, and storage. Watch for coarse, overmature hay, check the mineral balance of the whole ration, and talk with your vet about Coastal bermuda if your horse has had an ileal impaction.
Which hay is cheapest for horses?
Usually whatever grows locally, since freight adds a lot to the price. In the South, that’s often bermuda, while timothy and alfalfa may be trucked in. Compare price per pound, not per bale, because bale weights vary.
Can teff be the main hay for a horse in hard work?
Yes, if its analysis fits the horse’s needs and the rest of the ration makes up any shortfalls. Late-cut teff can be lower in protein and digestibility, so let the hay test and the horse’s condition guide what else you feed.

About Miles Henry
Racehorse Owner & Author | 30+ Years in Thoroughbred Racing
Miles Henry (legal name: William Bradley) is a professional horseman based in Folsom, Louisiana. He holds Louisiana Racing License #67012 and has spent over three decades managing Thoroughbreds at premier tracks including Fair Grounds, Delta Downs, and Evangeline Downs.
Expertise & Hands-On Experience: Beyond the track, Miles has decades of experience in specialized equine care, covering everything from hoof health and nutrition to training protocols for Quarter Horses, Friesians, and Paints. Every guide on Horse Racing Sense is rooted in this “boots-on-the-ground” perspective.
30 of their last 90 starts
Equibase Profile.
Connect with Miles:
