Which Horse Riding Helmets Offer Better Protection?

Last updated: November 16, 2026

By: Miles HenryFact Checked

Any links on this page that lead to products on Amazon are affiliate links and I earn a commission if you make a purchase. Thanks in advance – I really appreciate it!

 

Riding helmets can look alike but vary widely in price. A safety label tells you which standard a helmet meets, but it doesn’t tell you exactly how much protection it provides in a fall. So how do you choose the best helmet for horse riding?

Quick answer: Start with a helmet that fits and meets a current safety standard, such as ASTM F1163 with the SEI tag in the U.S. Then check the exact model in Virginia Tech’s independent equestrian helmet ratings, where more stars mean lower predicted concussion risk in the lab’s tests. In Virginia Tech’s 2025 study, the Champion REVOLVE X-Air MIPS Peaked ranked first with five stars. Price doesn’t guarantee protection, and no helmet can prevent every head injury.

Every exercise rider and pony rider on my horses wears a helmet. Here’s how I compare safety ratings, what riders use around our barn, and what to check for jumping, fit, and replacement.

What Makes a Riding Helmet Safe?

Horseman’s Take A friend’s daughter once asked to ride one of my young horses. She was an experienced rider, but mostly on bombproof horses. She got on, and he threw her off almost right away. Her head hit the ground, and she was wearing a helmet. Thankfully, she wasn’t hurt. That’s why every rider on my horses wears one.

I look at three things: certification, independent impact ratings, and fit. They answer different questions, and none of them can be judged by a helmet’s price or looks.

Certification: The Minimum

Make sure the helmet meets an accepted equestrian safety standard. In the U.S., look for ASTM F1163 with the SEI tag inside the helmet. Certification means the helmet passed the required safety tests. It doesn’t mean every certified helmet protects equally.

If you compete, check your organization’s current helmet rules before you buy. Accepted standards and required certification labels can differ, and a helmet that met the rules when you bought it may not meet them years later.

Virginia Tech Ratings: Comparing Helmet Protection

The Virginia Tech Helmet Lab equestrian ratings compare certified helmets beyond the pass-or-fail tests. The lab rates helmets from zero to five stars, with more stars indicating lower predicted concussion risk in its tests. It built those tests from more than 100 videos of real riders falling, and it measures rotational head motion as well as straight-line impact.

In 2025, the lab updated the ratings after testing 49 helmets and adding high-speed falls like the ones riders take in racing and cross-country. Helmets performed differently under the new tests, so older star ratings quoted online may not match the updated results. The lab published its method and scores in a 2025 study in the Annals of Biomedical Engineering, where lower scores mean lower concussion risk.

The original results showed why price alone is a poor guide. When the lab released its first equestrian ratings, US Equestrian reported that one of the two five-star helmets retailed for $460 and the other for $58.

Dressage riders wearing riding helmets
Dressage riders in helmets at a show.

Best Riding Helmets by Safety Rating

These picks come from Virginia Tech’s independent testing, not my own crash testing. Scores below are from the lab’s 2025 study, where a lower STAR score means lower predicted concussion risk. The lab rates individual models, not brands, and helmets from the same company can score very differently.

Top-rated riding helmets in Virginia Tech testing
HelmetStyleStarsSTAR score
Champion REVOLVE X-Air MIPS PeakedPeaked52.11
Champion Revolve X-Air MIPSSkull cap42.67
Champion Revolve Vent-Air MIPS PeakedPeaked, extra ventilation42.90
Champion Revolve Pro Plus MIPS JockeySkull cap43.05
Champion X-Air Plus JockeySkull cap43.36
Trauma Void Lynx Eventing MIPSSkull cap43.42
Trauma Void EQ3 MIPSPeaked43.65

Champion takes the top spots, but look at the exact model. In the same study, the Champion Revolve Vent-Air MIPS Jockey scored three stars, a full star below its peaked version. If you’re on a budget, the Tipperary Sportage Hybrid scored three stars, with a STAR score of 4.30.

The Helmets We Use Around Our Barn

Around our barn, our exercise riders wear Troxel helmets, mostly the Dakota and the Spirit. The Ovation Deluxe Schooler is another popular helmet here. All three are ASTM/SEI certified, but they don’t score the same in independent testing. In Virginia Tech’s 2025 study, the Troxel Spirit scored one star and the Ovation Deluxe Schooler scored two stars. The Dakota wasn’t among the helmets tested. I’m including them because they’re what I see riders wear every morning, not because they’re top performers in the lab.

  • Troxel Dakota (not included in the 2025 study). A low-profile trail helmet with an extended visor for sun protection, seven mesh-covered vents, and a removable, washable liner, according to Tractor Supply.
  • Troxel Spirit (one star). A deeper, full-coverage schooling helmet with a dial fit system and a washable liner, according to Weaver Equine.
  • Ovation Deluxe Schooler (two stars). A low-profile schooling helmet with a dial adjuster, high-flow vents, a washable liner, and a breakaway visor, according to Schneider Saddlery.

Knowing those results, I’d look hard at the top-rated helmets above before buying for myself. Whatever helmet you choose, buy one you’ll actually wear every ride. A five-star helmet hanging in the tack room doesn’t protect anybody.

Best Helmet for Horse Jumping

Virginia Tech doesn’t publish a separate ranking of jumping helmets, but its ratings are a useful starting point. The lab includes impact tests that simulate falls when a horse is traveling at speed, which matters when you’re comparing helmets for jumping and cross-country. For show jumping and flatwork, the Champion REVOLVE X-Air MIPS Peaked belongs on the shortlist because of its top result. It still needs to fit you and meet your competition’s rules.

If you compete, check the current helmet requirements for your discipline and governing organization before you buy. For cross-country, many event riders choose a skull cap with no fixed peak and wear it with a silk cover. That design alone doesn’t mean better protection, so compare the exact model’s rating.

Look for ventilation that suits the conditions you ride in, but don’t accept a loose fit for comfort. If the helmet shifts as you ride, have the fit and harness adjustment checked.

Jockey wearing a skull cap helmet aboard a racehorse
A jockey in a skull cap with a silk cover.

Types of Riding Helmets

Common types of riding helmets
TypeBest forWhat to know
Schooling helmetEveryday riding, jumping, and lessonsVented, with a peak; the most common style
Show helmetHunters, equitation, and dressageVelvet or a sleek finish for the show ring
Skull capCross-country, eventing, and racingNo fixed peak; usually worn with a silk cover
Trail helmetTrail and pleasure ridingOften has a wider visor for sun protection

These categories describe style and use, not safety. A helmet with more coverage, a thicker shell, or a higher price isn’t automatically safer, so check the certification and rating of the exact model.

How to Fit a Riding Helmet

A top rating doesn’t make up for a poor fit. The University of Connecticut suggests a few checks:

  • Wiggle test. When you wiggle the helmet, your eyebrows should move with it.
  • Shake test. Bend at the waist and shake your head. The helmet should stay put.
  • Wear test. Wear it for several minutes. Painful pressure points or deep marks on your forehead mean you may need a different size or shape.
  • Coverage. The helmet should sit level, cover your forehead, and not block your vision.
  • Harness. Adjust the harness so it’s snug, following the manufacturer’s fitting instructions.

Try on several brands if you can. Head shapes vary, and a helmet that’s comfortable on one rider can pinch another. If you’re buying for a child, I cover youth options in the best riding helmets for kids.

How to fit a riding helmet.

When to Replace a Riding Helmet

If your helmet takes an impact in a fall, stop using it and follow the manufacturer’s replacement instructions, even if it looks fine. Damage inside a helmet isn’t always visible. If you’re not sure whether it was damaged, contact the manufacturer before you ride in it again.

For routine replacement, follow the manufacturer’s schedule, and replace a helmet sooner if the shell, harness, or buckle is damaged. Heat, sunlight, and poor storage can shorten its life, so I keep helmets somewhere cool and dry instead of in a hot truck or trailer.

A good helmet is only one part of riding safely. I cover the rest in is riding a horse dangerous.

Exercise rider wearing a helmet on a black Thoroughbred
An exercise rider in a helmet on a Thoroughbred.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *