Last updated: November 17, 2026
Your horse is dropping wads of hay, good bales are getting hard to find, or you’re tired of hauling hay to shows. A bag of pellets looks easier, but is it as good as a bale?
Here’s what changes when hay becomes a pellet or a cube, how much to feed, and what to look for on the bag.
Table of Contents
Hay Pellets vs. Hay: What Changes
Hay pellets start as cut, dried hay, usually alfalfa, though timothy, bermuda, and blends are common too. The hay is ground fine and pressed through a die under heat and pressure. Pelleted hay is still forage, not grain, and grinding doesn’t remove the fiber.
What grinding changes is the particle size. The University of Minnesota Extension lists both alfalfa pellets and hay cubes as feeds that can totally replace hay, with nutrition similar to hay. The drawback is that horses usually eat them faster and may overeat. Less chewing also means less saliva. If the horse finishes its ration quickly, it may spend long stretches with nothing left to eat.
| Feature | Hay pellets | Hay cubes | Baled hay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processing | Ground fine, then pressed | Chopped, then pressed | Dried in its long-stem form |
| Particle length | Very short | Shorter than hay, longer than pellets | Long-stem |
| Eating speed | Usually fast | Often slower than pellets | Usually slowest |
| Can replace hay? | Yes, fed by weight with the ration balanced | Yes, fed by weight with the ration balanced | The forage base for most horses |
| Bad teeth | Good option when soaked | Useful when soaked | Often difficult |
| Best use | Soaked mash, seniors, supplement carrier, travel | Partial forage, travel, hay extender | Main forage for horses that can chew it |

Alfalfa Pellets vs. Alfalfa Hay
Alfalfa pellets and alfalfa hay start with the same forage, so pellets can provide much of the same nutrition as the hay they’re made from. But don’t assume every bag matches the hay in your barn. Protein, calories, fiber, and minerals vary with the quality of the original crop and how it was harvested. One advantage of pellets is the guaranteed analysis on the tag. Kentucky Equine Research notes that pellets and cubes carry guaranteed protein, fat, and fiber levels on the bag or feed tag, while baled hay can vary from field to field. Those guarantees are handy for comparing products, but they aren’t a full nutrient analysis, and with baled hay you need a forage test to know exactly what you’re feeding.
The trade-off is that you can’t see inside a pellet. KER notes that weeds are easy to spot in loose hay and impossible to pinpoint in pellets or cubes, so buy from a manufacturer you trust.
| Feature | Alfalfa hay | Alfalfa pellets |
|---|---|---|
| Nutrition | Depends on the crop and cutting stage | Depends on the source hay; tag lists nutrient guarantees |
| Storage | Takes more space | Easier to store and haul |
| Waste | Can be a lot | Usually less |
| Measuring | Flake weights vary | Easy to weigh |
| Inspection | You can see each flake | You can’t see the original crop |
Neither form automatically gives better nutrition. If your horse is doing well on alfalfa hay, pellets aren’t a nutritional upgrade, but they can make feeding easier when storage, hauling, waste, or chewing becomes a problem.
Either form carries alfalfa’s extra calcium, so if alfalfa makes up most of the ration, have the whole diet balanced. I cover amounts and risks for alfalfa in general in how much alfalfa to feed a horse.
Where Hay Cubes Fit
Cubes are the middle ground. The hay is chopped instead of ground, then pressed into blocks about an inch or two across, so the pieces are longer than in a pellet. Rutgers Cooperative Extension says cubes can supply all the forage for a horse that can’t manage long-stem hay, and smaller amounts can stretch a limited hay supply.
If cubes will provide all the forage, Rutgers recommends grass cubes or an alfalfa-grass mix for most adult horses, since straight alfalfa cubes carry more protein and calcium than they need. That still leaves the rest of the diet to balance, because ordinary hay cubes aren’t a complete feed. Feed cubes by weight rather than in unlimited amounts. A University of Kentucky Extension guide warns that horses eat 17% to 25% more cubes than long-stem hay when fed to appetite.
When to Choose Pellets, Cubes, or Hay
- Hay: if the horse is doing well on good long-stem hay and can chew it, stay with it. It’s usually the cheapest option where decent hay is local.
- Soaked pellets: for worn or missing teeth, or a horse that drops wads of hay. More on older horses in the best hay for senior horses.
- Cubes or pellets for convenience: hauling, limited storage, or riding out a hay shortage. Other options for a shortage are in hay alternatives for horses.
- For a fast eater or a choke history: soak pellets or cubes before feeding.
Alfalfa Pellets Feeding Guide
Start with the horse’s total forage needs, not a fixed scoop of pellets. The University of Minnesota Extension uses about 2% of body weight in hay a day as a general starting point, roughly 20 pounds for a 1,000-pound horse without pasture. That isn’t a blanket recommendation to feed 20 pounds of straight alfalfa pellets; the forage type and the rest of the diet still need to suit the horse. I break the daily amount down further in how much hay to feed a horse.
- As a supplement: a pound or two of alfalfa pellets on top of a hay ration adds some protein and calories, or carries a supplement.
- As a hay extender: replace part of the hay by weight. Rutgers says 2 to 6 pounds of cubes a day can stretch a limited hay supply. Replacing grass hay with alfalfa pellets changes more than the form of the feed, so account for the extra protein and calcium.
- As all the forage: build up to the horse’s full daily forage by weight, divided into several smaller feedings so the horse isn’t left with long stretches and nothing to eat. Follow the bag’s directions, and have the whole diet checked by your vet or an equine nutritionist.
Weigh pellets and cubes instead of counting scoops, because density changes from product to product, and weigh them before soaking, not after adding water. Pellets and cubes provide forage, but they don’t give a horse the chewing time a flake of hay does, and some horses pick up habits like chewing wood without it. If your horse can chew long-stem hay safely, KER suggests offering a half pound to a pound a day to keep a horse on a pelleted or cubed diet occupied. For a horse that drops wads of hay, ask your vet whether long-stem forage is appropriate.

How to Pick a Bag of Hay Pellets
The right pellets depend on your horse and what you’re feeding them for, so read the tag before you buy:
- Ingredients: 100% alfalfa, a grass hay like timothy or bermuda, a blend, or a fortified feed with grain and vitamins added.
- Protein and calories: alfalfa pellets generally run higher in protein than grass-hay pellets, but compare the analysis with what your horse needs instead of choosing by name alone.
- Sugar and starch: look for NSC numbers if you’re feeding a metabolic horse.
- Calcium and phosphorus: especially if alfalfa will be a big share of the ration.
- Feeding directions: a straight forage pellet is fed like hay, while a complete feed has its own directions.
If the pellets will be the horse’s main forage, ask the manufacturer for a full analysis. The University of Minnesota guide to hay analysis explains how to read one, and the guide to choosing hay for horses covers what to look for in the hay you’re replacing.
Feeding Pellets and Cubes Safely
A sudden switch, a big meal eaten too fast, or dry feed given to a horse with bad teeth or a choke history can all cause trouble.
- Switch over 7 to 14 days. Add a little of the new feed and cut the hay back by the same weight as you go.
- Split big rations into several meals.
- Soak when needed, for horses with bad teeth, a choke history, or a habit of bolting feed. Rutgers recommends soaking hay cubes for 10 minutes before feeding. Pellets and other products may need different times, so follow the manufacturer’s directions and make sure the feed has fully softened.
- Keep clean water in front of the horse at all times.
- Throw out soaked leftovers before they spoil, especially in hot weather.
This video from the Ask the Vet series, Should I Feed Alfalfa Cubes or Pellets?, walks through the choice.
Hay Pellet FAQs
Are alfalfa pellets roughage or concentrate?
Plain alfalfa pellets are forage, not a grain concentrate. Pelleting changes the form of the hay, not its classification as roughage.
Do hay pellets need to be soaked?
Not always. A healthy horse with good teeth that eats at a normal pace can eat many pellets dry. Soak them for horses with bad teeth, a choke history, or a habit of bolting feed.
Are hay pellets cheaper than hay?
Not necessarily. Bagged pellets and cubes often cost more per pound than local baled hay, but they cut waste and are easier to haul and store. Compare price per pound, not per bag or bale.

About Miles Henry
Racehorse Owner & Author | 30+ Years in Thoroughbred Racing
Miles Henry (legal name: William Bradley) is a professional horseman based in Folsom, Louisiana. He holds Louisiana Racing License #67012 and has spent over three decades managing Thoroughbreds at premier tracks including Fair Grounds, Delta Downs, and Evangeline Downs.
Expertise & Hands-On Experience: Beyond the track, Miles has decades of experience in specialized equine care, covering everything from hoof health and nutrition to training protocols for Quarter Horses, Friesians, and Paints. Every guide on Horse Racing Sense is rooted in this “boots-on-the-ground” perspective.
30 of their last 90 starts
Equibase Profile.
Connect with Miles:

